Used- ★ Cheapest
Vintage Pflueger Supreme level wind fishing reel made in USA
$11.99 + $8.50 shipping
No model number or condition stated. Budget for a clean.
tsme35
99.9% positive

For decades the Supreme was Pflueger's top American level-wind casting reel.
Decades-old oil gums up the gears and level wind, and a Supreme that turns stiffly usually just needs cleaning.
The Supreme to fish is the 1573, the common level wind, and one with its box and pamphlet asks just $30 delivered. Most complete reels ask $30 to $45. The model number, a box and early versions like the 610B and the narrow-spool 1577 push prices up. Check the marbled handle for cracks. Spin-cast Supremes share the search, and the bare $331.49 reel gives no reason for its price.
Delivered prices include shipping as eBay quoted it to a US address on Oct 19, 2026. Many sellers charge by distance, so your total may differ. eBay shows yours before you pay.

No model number or condition in the title, but $20.49 delivered is the low total. Budget a clean and check the level wind in the photos.
Vintage Pflueger Supreme level wind fishing reel made in USA

A 1573 with its box and pamphlet for $30 delivered, at the bottom of the band. The other boxed 1573 here asks $34.50, so you get the paperwork almost free.
Vintage Pflueger Supreme No.1573 Reel W/Box & Pamphlet

The 1573 is the Supreme we'd fish, and at $30 a backlash or two while you learn to thumb the spool costs little. Expect it to want fresh oil after years in the box.
Vintage Pflueger Supreme No.1573 Reel W/Box & Pamphlet

The only cheap Supreme listed as working with smooth action, at $13.98 before shipping. Shipping isn't stated, so get the delivered total first.
Pflueger Supreme Vintage Fishing Reel Bait cast Working Smooth Action USA

An early 610B in its hexagonal box, described as smooth-running and fully functional. At $119 delivered it's collector money for a reel you can still fish.
Pflueger Supreme #610B L/W Reel Smooth-Running Fully Functional w/Hexagonal Box
Checked . Some may have sold.
Delivered prices include shipping as eBay quoted it to a US address on Oct 19, 2026. Many sellers charge by distance, so your total may differ. eBay shows yours before you pay.
UsedVintage Pflueger Supreme level wind fishing reel made in USA
$11.99 + $8.50 shipping
No model number or condition stated. Budget for a clean.
tsme35
99.9% positive
UsedVintage Pflueger Supreme No.1573 Reel W/Box & Pamphlet
$20.00 + $10.00 shipping
A 1573 with box and pamphlet at a bare-reel price.
rubbercityfishing
100% positive
UsedPflueger Supreme Vintage Fishing Reel Bait cast Working Smooth Action USA
$13.98 · shipping not stated
This seller takes offers, and many sellers accept less than the asking price.
Fine if you might miss it? Send an offer first. Someone else can still buy it while you wait for a reply.
Want it for sure? Use Buy It Now.
Working with smooth action, per the seller. Shipping not stated.
mcle5938
100% positive
UsedPflueger Supreme #610B L/W Reel Smooth-Running Fully Functional w/Hexagonal Box
$110.00 + $9.00 shipping
This seller takes offers, and many sellers accept less than the asking price.
Fine if you might miss it? Send an offer first. Someone else can still buy it while you wait for a reply.
Want it for sure? Use Buy It Now.
Early 610B with hex box, smooth and fully functional per the seller.
kingsalmon
99.8% positive
UsedVINTAGE PFLUEGER Supreme # 1573 Level Wind Reel W/box
$28.00 + $6.50 shipping
This seller takes offers, and many sellers accept less than the asking price.
Fine if you might miss it? Send an offer first. Someone else can still buy it while you wait for a reply.
Want it for sure? Use Buy It Now.
Another boxed 1573, a few dollars more than the pick.
kingcb
100% positive
UsedVintage Pflueger Supreme Bait Cast Reel Very Nice Please Read Description
$35.00 + $9.00 shipping
This seller takes offers, and many sellers accept less than the asking price.
Fine if you might miss it? Send an offer first. Someone else can still buy it while you wait for a reply.
Want it for sure? Use Buy It Now.
Seller calls it very nice and asks you to read the description. Do, before you buy.
micwo_1883
99.9% positive
UsedVintage Pflueger Supreme 1577 Narrow Spool Tournament Style Reel in Black Case
$179.98 · shipping not stated
This seller takes offers, and many sellers accept less than the asking price.
Fine if you might miss it? Send an offer first. Someone else can still buy it while you wait for a reply.
Want it for sure? Use Buy It Now.
The scarcer narrow-spool 1577 tournament reel in a case. A specialist buy, and shipping isn't stated.
hjpsales
99.7% positive
UsedVintage Pflueger Supreme Bait Casting Fishing Reel Made in USA
$314.99 + $16.50 shipping
This seller takes offers, and many sellers accept less than the asking price.
Fine if you might miss it? Send an offer first. Someone else can still buy it while you wait for a reply.
Want it for sure? Use Buy It Now.
About seven times the band's top, and the listing gives no reason.
goldenestategoods
99.6% positive
Prices change daily. The live eBay search shows everything listed now, including anything new since Oct 19, 2026.
See every listing on eBay ⟶For decades the Supreme was Pflueger's top American level-wind casting reel. The Enterprise Manufacturing Company built it in Akron, Ohio, from the 1920s, and the common 1573 stayed on offer until the late 1960s.
Even the first ones had an automatic free-spool and an adjustable anti-backlash control, which made them serious bass reels in their day. Now they're everywhere.
About 48 showed up in our latest snapshot, most at $25 to $60 delivered, and the 1573 with its marbled handle is the one you'll see most. Collectors pay up for boxed sets with papers, early versions and the narrow-spool 1577 tournament reel.
A few sellers were asking far more than the market, so compare a handful of listings before you buy. For a reel to fish, we'd take a clean 1573 with an uncracked handle.