The Pflueger Medalist 1494 is the classic American trout fly reel, and Pflueger has made it since 1929. It's a simple single-action reel about 3¼ inches across, with a click and an adjustable drag.
Pflueger of Akron, Ohio, applied for the design patent in 1928. Shakespeare bought the company in 1966 and kept making Medalists in Akron until the end of the 1960s.
From 1970 they came from Asia, and letter codes after the model number mark those later reels, CJ for Japan and AK for Hong Kong or China. Most of the 36 in our latest snapshot were later reels at $40 to $75 delivered.
The collector money goes to early Akron reels with a patent-pending marking, sculpted pillars or a round line guide, and those can fetch $125 and more. On any of them, listen for a crisp, even click and check that the spool latch holds.
Its 1929 start puts it on our 1940s page, the earliest decade we list.