Penn has built the Jigmaster 500 since 1959, and it's still the do-everything boat reel. It's a mid-size star-drag conventional for bottom fishing, light jigging and inshore work.
Alongside it Penn made a narrow-spool 501 from 1966 to 2004 and a short-lived 500S from 1975 to 1984. Production of the 500 moved to China in 2006, which is why vintage buyers look for the older reels.
The classic look is maroon Bakelite with a red knob. It's simple inside and Penn parts are easy to find, which makes it one of the best-value vintage saltwater reels around.
Our latest snapshot had about 44 listed, most working reels at $30 to $60 delivered, and boxed new-old-stock reels still turn up under $100. Many Jigmasters have been fitted with aftermarket spools, frames or handles for jigging or casting.
Decide first whether you want an original or a tuned reel, then check the photos to see which one you're getting.